Filters
Best Sellers
-
Sale
$1.99Creme Savers Strawberries and Creme 3oz Bag
Iconic CandyCrème Savers are a taste of fresh strawberries swirled with rich crème. Back after a decade Strawberry Creme Savers are individually wrapped ha...
View full details$1.99Sale -
Sold out
from $1.39NECCO Wafers 2oz Package or 24 Count Box
Spangler Candy CompanyThey are finally back!!! We have waited a long time for these candy wafers to come back and they are finally here after more than 2 years! The same...
View full detailsfrom $1.39Sold out -
Sale
from $0.59Candy Cigarettes Original 15gr. Pack or 24 Count Box
World ConfectionsThere is no candy that contains as much nostalgia as these candy cigarettes. Buy a box or even ten and indulge in a candy that we know you love and...
View full detailsfrom $0.59Sale -
Sale
from $1.99Wacky Wafer 1.2oz or 24 Count Box
Leaf BrandsThey're Back!!!Just like the original, these five flavor and five wafer Wacky Wafers come in a clear wrap and are approximately 1 1/2 inches. Now t...
View full detailsfrom $1.99Sale -
Sale
from $0.79Zotz Strings Cherry, Watermelon, Apple .7oz String or 48 Count Box
Andre ProstFizz, Fizz, and more Fizz. Zotz are just the thing you need to wake your taste buds up. The incredible flavored hard candy with a fizzy center. Jus...
View full detailsfrom $0.79Sale -
Sale
from $1.29Candy Button .25oz Long Strip 2 Pack or 24 Count Box
Doscher's CandiesThis very nostalgic candy has satisfied candy-lovers for years! These buttons are the perfect gift for kids and adults any time of the year.
from $1.29Sale -
Sold out
from $0.99DISCONTINUED ITEM - Whistle Pop .53oz Single or 48 Count Box
Euro-American BrandsSo what is better than a normal lollipop? These are! These whistle pops are just in the name, they can be used as a real whistle. Use these strawbe...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sold out -
Sale
from $1.39Cadbury Curly Wurly 1.4oz Bar or 48 Count Box
CadburyThis delicious candy bar is woven into our DNA. We know you will love the Curly Wurly with it's smooth milk chocolate and chewy caramel helix-ed to...
View full detailsfrom $1.39Sale -
Sale
$9.99Ice Cubes Original 21 Count Box Milk Chocolate
R.L.Alberts & SonsRanked as one of the best Nostalgic chocolate candies ever! Ice Cubes are the smoothest, creamiest chocolate candies ever made. Made with real coco...
View full details$9.99Sale -
Sale
from $0.79Zotz Strings Blue Raspberry, Orange, Grape .7oz String or 48 Count Box
Andre ProstA hard exterior, but a wonderful fizzy center filled with a delicious sour powder. Bite into these candies and let the fizziness take over your tas...
View full detailsfrom $0.79Sale -
Sale
$1.99Creme Savers Orange and Creme 3oz Bag
Iconic CandyCrème Savers are a taste of fresh oranges swirled with rich crème. Back after a decade Orange Creme Savers are individually wrapped hard candy ...
View full details$1.99Sale -
Sale
from $0.69Smarties Candy Necklace .75oz Piece or 24 Count Box
Smarties Candy CompanyAn easy addition to kid's parties, birthday presents, stocking stuffers, or just for fun! Try this nostalgic brand of candy necklaces to experience...
View full detailsfrom $0.69Sale -
Sale
from $1.29Boyer Mallo Cup 1.5oz Piece or 24 Count Box
Boyer Candy CompanySo stuffed full of marshmallowy goodness, it will be squishing between your fingers. This item has been a candy-lovers favorite for decades!
from $1.29Sale -
Sale
from $0.39Lemonheads .8oz Box or 24 Count Pack
Ferrara Candy CompanyChewy, sour, and sweet! All the best mouth temptations in one, perfectly packaged, small, on-the-go box! Share if you like or just keep it for your...
View full detailsfrom $0.39Sale -
Sold out
from $1.29Chunky Original 1.4oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
Ferrero USAA taste from the past. Chunky is a must have in rain or shine, there's always time! A Chunky bar will take you through a whirlwind of retro flavors...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
Sold out
from $0.59Goetze's Cow Tales Vanilla 1oz Piece or 36 Count Box
Goetze Candy CompanyThe Original Cow Tale! These Vanilla Cow Tales are made with delicious, chewy caramel filled with cream.
from $0.59Sold out -
Sale
from $0.39Pumpkin Seeds Indian Brand 9gr Pack or 36 Count Box
Zenobia CompanyWow-ee these seeds are salty! Indian Brand Pumpkin Seeds are roasted with a heavy coating of salt and the shell is thin enough they don't have to b...
View full detailsfrom $0.39Sale -
Sale
from $1.99Tart N Tinys 1.5oz or 24 Count Box
Leaf BrandsThey're Back!!!They may be tiny but wow do they pack a punch. Tart N Tinys are tiny, fruit-flavored candies that have just the right balance betwee...
View full detailsfrom $1.99Sale -
Sale
from $1.29Razzles Original Gum 1.4oz Pack or 24 Count Box
Charms CompanyIs it candy or is it gum? It's both! Razzles are a unique piece of candy that turns into gum once chewed! See for yourself what everyone's talking ...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sale -
Sale
from $0.59Smarties 1oz Giant Roll or 36 Count Box
Smarties Candy CompanySmarties are a colorful and soft, dissolvable candy. Family owned since 1949, this candy is an all-American favorite from then to now.
from $0.59Sale -
Sale
from $1.99Astro Pops 1oz Piece or 24 Count Box
Leaf BrandsThey're Back!!! You don't have to be a rocket scientist to know that Astro Pops have incredible flavor. Whether they bring back memories or help yo...
View full detailsfrom $1.99Sale -
Sale
from $1.39Caramel Creams 1.9oz Candy Bar or 20 Count Box
Goetze Candy CompanyCaramel Creams are a nostalgic candy that everybody loves. They have a caramel that isn't too sticky, and a creamy center that is just sweet enough...
View full detailsfrom $1.39Sale -
Sale
from $1.29BarNone 1.48oz Candy Bar or 24 Count box
Iconic CandyIt's Back!! Bar None candy bar is finally back after over 20 years. Just as delicious as before, this candy bar contains a crispy chocolate wafer a...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sale -
Sale
from $0.39Boston Baked Beans .8oz Box or 24 Count Pack
Ferrara Candy CompanyThe crunchiest and sweetest bean you will ever try! This nostalgic item is guaranteed to bring a smile to your face as you fill your mouth full wit...
View full detailsfrom $0.39Sale