Nostalgic
-
from $0.49Lemonheads .8oz Box or 24 Count Pack
Ferrara Candy CompanyChewy, sour, and sweet! All the best mouth temptations in one, perfectly packaged, small, on-the-go box! Share if you like or just keep it for your...
View full detailsfrom $0.49 -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Alexander the Grape 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 Candy"The sweet taste of victory!" Alexander the Grape are refreshingly grape, chewy, and delicious.
from $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Cherry Clan 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 CandyThe Cherry Clan Ninjas have come to attack your taste buds....with flavor! Each bite of this chewy candy is like a punch to the mouth with deliciou...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Johnny Apple Treats 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 Candy"Treat others as you would treat yourself!"
from $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Mr. Melon 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 Candy"Treat others as you would treat yourself!"
from $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Spree Chewy 1.7oz or 24 Count Box
Ferrara Candy CompanyA chewy version of the original fruity disk candy in an assortment of bright colors and fruit flavors, Chewy Sprees are sure to surprise and deligh...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.69Sweetarts Giant Chewy 1.5oz or 36 Count Box
Ferrara Candy CompanyGiant Chewy Disks of Sweetart fun! These delicious candies come in red, purple, green, and yellow. Cherry (red) Grape (purple) Lemon (yellow) G...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sold out -
from $0.33Mike And Ike .78oz or 24 Count Box
Just BornMike and Ike are a delicious, chewy, and sweet candy. These boxes are the perfect size for a small candy treat. Put them in your purse or car for a...
View full detailsfrom $0.33 -
from $1.69Bit O Honey 4oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
Spangler Candy CompanyWhat has real honey, almond bits, and has been made with the same recipe since 1924? Sounds like a candy I want to try. It's Bit-O-Honey! Made with...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
Sold out
from $0.39DISCONTINUED ITEM - Appleheads .8oz Box or 24 Count Pack
Ferrara Candy CompanyIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39Sold out -
from $0.39Airheads White Mystery .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39 -
from $2.39Bit-O-Honey 4.2oz Bag or 12 Count Case
Spangler Candy CompanyBit-O-Honey has just the right amount of honey and chewy texture. Candy lovers have been a fan of this item for decades and still it remains famous!
from $2.39 -
from $0.29Long Boys Coconut 9.5gr or 48 Count Box
Atkinson Candy CompanyWhat is a 3 inches long brown candy with a yellow and red wrapper and is a chewy caramel with coconut flakes? Coconut Long Boys of course! A perfec...
View full detailsfrom $0.29 -
from $1.69Tootsie Roll 2.25oz or 36 Count Box
Tootsie RollThese chewy, chocolate candies are downright delectable. In 1896, Austrian immigrant, Leo Hirshfeld set out to make a candy that would not melt in ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
from $1.69Lemonheads 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Case
Ferrara Candy CompanyChewy, sour, and sweet! All the best mouth temptations in one package! Lemonheads will surely take your taste buds on a grand adventure!
from $1.69 -
Sold out
from $1.69DISCONTINUED ITEM - Lemonhead & Friends Chewy Fruit Mix 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Case
Ferrara Candy CompanyChewy, sour, and sweet! All the best mouth temptations in one package! Lemonheads will surely take your taste buds on a grand adventure!
from $1.69Sold out -
Sold out
$14.75DISCONTINUED ITEM - BB Bat 100 Count Assorted Flavors
Runk Candy CompanyCreated in 1924, BB Bats have been a nostalgic favorite for decades. Available in 4 classic flavors and just right for any occasion.
$14.75Sold out -
Sold out
from $0.29DISCONTINUED ITEM - Long Boys Chocolate 9.5gr or 48 Count Box
Atkinson Candy CompanyMade with real chocolate, loaded with a chewy texture, and totally Kosher! How can you go wrong with a Chocolate Long Boy!?
from $0.29Sold out -
Sold out
$11.99Licorice Snaps 12oz Bag Limited Edition
American Licorice CompanyOh Snap! These delicious and coated black licorice treats are back but only for limited time!! So make sure to get them before they all get snapped...
View full details$11.99Sold out -
from $1.69Peanut Chews Original 2oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
Just BornPeanut Chews are celebrating 100 years of chewy, peanutty goodness! This candy bar is consistent and never disappointing!
from $1.69 -
$26.75McCraws Taffy .75oz Assorted Flavors 24 Count Box
Hammond's CandiesAn easy to chew, easy to love nostalgic taffy! McCraws Taffy wasn't being made for a long time, but now it's back and it's better than ever!
$26.75 -
$16.75Airheads .55oz Bar 60 Count Box Assorted
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
$16.75 -
from $0.39Airheads Blue Raspberry .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39 -
from $0.39Airheads Cherry .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39 -
Sold out
from $0.39Airheads Grape .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39Sold out -
Sold out
from $0.39Airheads Green Apple .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39Sold out -
from $0.39Airheads Orange .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39 -
from $0.39Airheads Watermelon .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39 -
Sold out
from $0.39Airheads Strawberry .55oz Bar or 36 Count Box
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39Sold out -
from $1.69Charleston Chew Strawberry 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
from $1.69Charleston Chew Chocolate 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
from $1.69Charleston Chew Vanilla 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
from $1.69Chuckles 2oz Piece or 24 Count Box
Ferrara Candy CompanyA delicious, chewy jelly candy with a light coating of sugar to give it that longed after taste. Chuckles have been around for decades, always prod...
View full detailsfrom $1.69 -
from $2.99Circus Peanuts 5oz Bag or 12 Count Case
Spangler Candy CompanyDating back to the 19th Century, Circus Peanuts were created with love and adventure in every ingredient! Candy lovers are still feeling the same t...
View full detailsfrom $2.99 -
from $1.49Coconut Bar 3 Color 2.5oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Dayton Nut SpecialtiesIf you like coconut, you will love these Neapolitan Coconut Bars. They are chewy and full of flavor in every single bit. You will not be disappointed.
from $1.49
