Filters
Products
-
from $1.49
Candy Button .25oz Long Strip 2 Pack or 24 Count Box
Doscher's CandiesThis very nostalgic candy has satisfied candy-lovers for years! These buttons are the perfect gift for kids and adults any time of the year.
from $1.49Sale -
from $0.59
Candy Cigarettes Original 15gr. Pack or 24 Count Box
World ConfectionsThere is no candy that contains as much nostalgia as these candy cigarettes. Buy a box or even ten and indulge in a candy that we know you love and...
View full detailsfrom $0.59Sold out -
from $1.69
Caramel Creams 1.9oz Candy Bar or 20 Count Box
Goetze Candy CompanyCaramel Creams are a nostalgic candy that everybody loves. They have a caramel that isn't too sticky, and a creamy center that is just sweet enough...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
$1.99
Caramel Creams Original 4oz Bag
Goetze Candy CompanyCaramel Creams are a nostalgic candy that everybody loves. They have a caramel that isn't too sticky, and a cream center that is just sweet enough!...
View full details$1.99Sale -
from $1.69
Charleston Chew Chocolate 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
from $1.69
Charleston Chew Strawberry 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
from $1.69
Charleston Chew Vanilla 1.875oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Tootsie RollCreated in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
from $2.39
Chick O Stick 3oz Bag or 12 Count Box
Atkinson Candy CompanyThis satisfying Chick-O-Stick is a little salty, a little sweet and a lot crunchy! Made with Atkinson's famous peanut butter, toasted coconut and c...
View full detailsfrom $2.39Sale -
from $1.69
Chick-O-Stick 1.6oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Atkinson Candy CompanyCrispy and crunchy peanut flavored stick. Chick-O-Sticks are crunchy peanut butter and toasted coconut packed into a delicious stick. These 1.6 oz ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
from $1.99
Chuckles 2oz Piece or 24 Count Box
Ferrara Candy CompanyA delicious, chewy jelly candy with a light coating of sugar to give it that longed after taste. Chuckles have been around for decades, always prod...
View full detailsfrom $1.99Sale -
from $1.69
Chunky Original 1.4oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
Ferrero USAA taste from the past. Chunky is a must have in rain or shine, there's always time! A Chunky bar will take you through a whirlwind of retro flavors...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
from $2.99
Circus Peanuts 5oz Bag or 12 Count Case
Spangler Candy CompanyDating back to the 19th Century, Circus Peanuts were created with love and adventure in every ingredient! Candy lovers are still feeling the same t...
View full detailsfrom $2.99Sale -
from $1.99
Clark Milk Chocolate 2oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
Boyer Candy CompanyClark Bars are everyone's favorite candy bar, admit it! Finally back tasting just as good as before. You can soon enjoy a Clark Bar from the moment...
View full detailsfrom $1.99Sold out -
from $0.99
Clove Gum 5 Stick Pack or 20 Count Box
Gerrit J. Verburg CompanyIt's back! After years of being off the market, Clove gum has returned, full of retro and nostalgic flavors. Let your tastebuds explode with memori...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sale -
from $1.69
Coconut Bar 3 Color 2.5oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Dayton Nut SpecialtiesIf you like coconut, you will love these Neapolitan Coconut Bars. They are chewy and full of flavor in every single bit. You will not be disappointed.
from $1.69Sale -
$1.99
Cow Tales Minis 4oz Bag
Goetze Candy CompanyThe Original Cow Tale! These Vanilla Cow Tales are made with delicious, chewy caramel filled with cream and are now mini!
$1.99Sale -
$1.99
Creme Savers Orange and Creme 3oz Bag
Iconic CandyCrème Savers are a taste of fresh oranges swirled with rich crème. Back after a decade Orange Creme Savers are individually wrapped hard candy ...
View full details$1.99Sold out -
$1.99
Creme Savers Strawberries and Creme 3oz Bag
Iconic CandyCrème Savers are a taste of fresh strawberries swirled with rich crème. Back after a decade Strawberry Creme Savers are individually wrapped ha...
View full details$1.99Sale -
from $1.69
Crunch 1.55oz Candy Bar or 36 Count Box
Ferrero USAThe Crunch bar is the chocolate candy bar with crisped rice you know and love!
from $1.69Sale -
from $7.99
Cut Rock 11oz
PrimroseEvoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Cut Rock hard candy. The centers have intricate designs and the flavors include a va...
View full detailsfrom $7.99Sale -
from $7.99
Deluxe Filled Mix 13oz
PrimroseEvoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Deluxe Filled hard candy mix. These colorful hard candies from Primrose look just li...
View full detailsfrom $7.99Sale -
from $1.69
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Alexander the Grape 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 Candy"The sweet taste of victory!" Alexander the Grape are refreshingly grape, chewy, and delicious.
from $1.69Sold out -
from $0.39
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Appleheads .8oz Box or 24 Count Pack
Ferrara Candy CompanyIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
from $0.39Sold out -
$19.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Atomic Fireball 150 Count Jar
Ferrara Candy CompanyCinnamon candy guaranteed to make your taste buds explode. Atomic Fireballs are individually wrapped and the perfect desk candy. Similar to a jawbr...
View full details$19.75Sold out -
$14.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - BB Bat 100 Count Assorted Flavors
Runk Candy CompanyCreated in 1924, BB Bats have been a nostalgic favorite for decades. Available in 4 classic flavors and just right for any occasion.
$14.75Sold out -
$18.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Beechies Peppermint Gum 2pk 100 Count Box
Roses BrandsEach box is 1.5 inches by 0.875 inches and includes 2 pieces of delicious gum. Beechies gum comes in the icy, refreshing flavor of peppermint.
$18.75Sold out -
from $1.29
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Big Cherry Dark Chocolate 1.75oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Adams & BrooksCovered by a rich cream, coated with dark chocolate and topped with peanuts, is where you will find the Big Cherry. Mm, now doesn't that sound so g...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
$43.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Bonomo Turkish Taffy Long Twist 192 Count Jar Banana Flavored
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the perfect, bite-size twists for on-the-go enjoyment.
$43.75Sold out -
$43.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Bonomo Turkish Taffy Long Twist 192 Count Jar Vanilla Flavored
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the perfect, bite-size twists for on-the-go enjoyment.
$43.75Sold out -
from $1.69
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Cherry Clan 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 CandyThe Cherry Clan Ninjas have come to attack your taste buds....with flavor! Each bite of this chewy candy is like a punch to the mouth with deliciou...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sold out -
$5.99
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Ferrero Rocher 5.3oz
Ferrero USARocher Chocolates are tempting combination of luscious, creamy, chocolatey filling surrounding a whole hazelnut, within a delicate, crisp wafer... ...
View full details$5.99Sold out -
from $1.69
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Johnny Apple Treats 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Box
1908 Candy"Treat others as you would treat yourself!"
from $1.69Sold out -
from $1.29
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Lance Peanut Bar 2.2oz Bar or 21 Count Box
LanceFresh roasted peanuts combine with fresh roasted peanuts to make up this peanut packed bar. Peanuts really shine through with only four simple ingr...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
from $1.69
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Lemonhead & Friends Chewy Fruit Mix 5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Case
Ferrara Candy CompanyChewy, sour, and sweet! All the best mouth temptations in one package! Lemonheads will surely take your taste buds on a grand adventure!
from $1.69Sold out -
$19.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Lemonheads 150 Count Jar
Ferrara Candy CompanyLemonheads are the perfect candy for those that enjoy lemon and sour candy. Just the right amount of sour pucker to sweet. These candies make a del...
View full details$19.75Sold out -
from $0.99
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Licorice Pipe Black 17gr or 60 Count Box
Warrell CorporationLicorice Pipes…the name says it all. A retro staple, these black licorice pipes are individually wrapped. Available in red licorice as well, you ca...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sold out