Nostalgic

Bonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the best, classic flavors for your enjoyment.

An easy to chew, easy to love nostalgic taffy! McCraws Taffy wasn't being made for a long time, but now it's back and it's better than ever!

Look! It's the richest, creamiest candy nougat for decades. Look candy bars will always have you Look!ing for more!

The Crunch bar is the chocolate candy bar with crisped rice you know and love!

Candy Crystals are a gorgeous, sweet rock candy. Full of flavor and perfect for events like weddings, graduations, and birthdays!

The mint with the hole. These delightful mints have been around for over 100 years. Each rolls contains 14 LifeSavers candies. The candy was design...

Annabelle’s Rocky Road bars are coated in smooth, handmade milk chocolate with a marshmallow interior. Cashews included. Bonus!

Oh Henry! chocolatey, peanutty, caramelly goodness. Each bar is peanut, caramel, and fudge coated in a delightful milk chocolate. Indulge in this i...

Evoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Cut Rock hard candy. The centers have intricate designs and the flavors include a va...

Evoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Baby Ribbon hard candy. Beautiful flowing ribbon candy in vibrant colors.

Evoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Filled Raspberry hard candy. A delicious raspberry shaped hard candy, lightly filled...

Evoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Old Fashion hard candy mix. These colorful hard candies from Primrose look just like...

Evoke the nostalgia of Grandma's candy dish with this Primrose Deluxe Filled hard candy mix. These colorful hard candies from Primrose look just li...

These holiday red and green spice drops are bursting with cinnamon and spearmint flavor. Packed in an acetate tub these spice drops are a holiday f...

These holiday wreaths are bursting with cherry and lime flavor. These bright red and green wreaths are perfect for snacking or decorating.

A Christmas favorite! Brach's peppermint nougats are a great item to serve on a dish during the Holidays or to throw in a stocking.

It's back! After years of being off the market, Teaberry gum has returned, full of retro and nostalgic flavors. Let your tastebuds explode with mem...

Nothing like triggering old memories with this nostalgic item! Identical to real ice cream cones and simply filled with so many flavors and colors.

They are finally back!!! We have waited a long time for these candy wafers to come back and they are finally here after more than 2 years! The same...

It's back! Tasting sweeter than ever, this creamy milk chocolate candy bar is filled with great taste and memories! Exactly like the original Skyba...

Do you miss the old Chiclets? So did we, until we tasted these Mini Mini Chicles. A little thicker, a little bigger, and a little lighter in color ...

Do you miss the old Chiclets? So did we, until we tasted these Mini Mini Chicles. A little thicker, a little bigger, and a little lighter in color ...

These leg lamp candies from A Christmas Story will arrive to you safe and sound in this FRAGILE box of tinned candy. Delightfully orange-flavored l...

Holiday themed edible slime, it's sour, sweet, and oozy good fun! It's easy to enjoy, the lid hides an attached spoon under the lid. Each snap-on l...

Rocky Road Mint is a handmade fluffy mint marshmallow covered with dark chocolate sprinkled with roasted cashew nuts.

Handcrafted fluffy vanilla marshmallow, topped with a delicate sprinkle of sea salt, and fresh roasted crushed cashews, individually enrobed in pre...

Rocky Road S’Mores is a handmade fluffy marshmallow with a graham cracker center covered in milk chocolate and topped with roasted cashew nuts.

Big Hunk is a chewy, honey-sweetened nougat bar with whole roasted almonds. Made in the USA.

Are you nutty for nuts? Try the nostalgic Old Dominion Peanut Bar. This salty-sweet snack will cure all your peanut cravings. This classic bar is p...

The great taste of Smarties in a fun liquid squeeze tube. Squeeze away this delicious liquid candy! Delicious Tart & Tangy Mixed-Fruit Flavors.

The amazing flavor of Warheads Sour Watermelon in a fun, squeezable tube. Hold onto your tongue for the unique sour explosion!! Warheads Sour Water...

A soft and chewy, crunchy, filled with caramel and chocolate covered, totally worth a hundred grand candy bar! There are so many layers of texture ...

This California candy bar is dubbed as "The best taffy/candy ever made!" and it's lived up to that for decades.

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

If you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!

So stuffed full of marshmallowy goodness, it will be squishing between your fingers. This item has been a candy-lovers favorite for decades!

Caramel Creams are a nostalgic candy that everybody loves. They have a caramel that isn't too sticky, and a creamy center that is just sweet enough...

There is no candy that contains as much nostalgia as these candy cigarettes. Buy a box or even ten and indulge in a candy that we know you love and...

Caramel Creams are a nostalgic candy that everybody loves. They have a caramel that isn't too sticky, and a cream center that is just sweet enough!...

Created in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...

Created in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...

Created in 1925, Charleston Chews have almost been around for a century! With a nice, chewy texture covered in chocolate, there is ALWAYS a reason ...