Filters
Nostalgic
-
Sale
from $1.79Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana 1.5oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the best, classic flavors for your enjoyment.
from $1.79Sale -
Sale
$26.75McCraws Taffy .75oz Assorted Flavors 24 Count Box
Hammond's CandiesAn easy to chew, easy to love nostalgic taffy! McCraws Taffy wasn't being made for a long time, but now it's back and it's better than ever!
$26.75Sale -
Sold out
from $1.69Look 1.5oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
AnnabelleLook! It's the richest, creamiest candy nougat for decades. Look candy bars will always have you Look!ing for more!
from $1.69Sold out -
Sale
from $1.69Crunch 1.55oz Candy Bar or 36 Count Box
Ferrero USAThe Crunch bar is the chocolate candy bar with crisped rice you know and love!
from $1.69Sale -
Sale
$69.75Rock Crystal .8oz Wrapped Candy Stick 60 Count Box
Roses BrandsCandy Crystals are a gorgeous, sweet rock candy. Full of flavor and perfect for events like weddings, graduations, and birthdays!
$69.75Sale -
Sold out
from $1.49LifeSavers Roll Pep-O-Mint .84oz Roll or 20 Count Box
Mars Wrigley ConfectioneryThe mint with the hole. These delightful mints have been around for over 100 years. Each rolls contains 14 LifeSavers candies. The candy was design...
View full detailsfrom $1.49Sold out -
Sale
from $1.69Rocky Road 1.65oz Bar Original
AnnabelleAnnabelle’s Rocky Road bars are coated in smooth, handmade milk chocolate with a marshmallow interior. Cashews included. Bonus!
from $1.69Sale -
Sold out
from $1.69Oh Henry 1.5oz Bar
Ferrero USAOh Henry! chocolatey, peanutty, caramelly goodness. Each bar is peanut, caramel, and fudge coated in a delightful milk chocolate. Indulge in this i...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sold out -
Sale
from $0.99Teaberry Gum 5 Stick Pack or 20 Count Box
Gerrit J. Verburg CompanyIt's back! After years of being off the market, Teaberry gum has returned, full of retro and nostalgic flavors. Let your tastebuds explode with mem...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sale -
Sold out
from $0.89Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones 2pack
Marpro Marshmallow ConeNothing like triggering old memories with this nostalgic item! Identical to real ice cream cones and simply filled with so many flavors and colors.
from $0.89Sold out -
Sale
from $1.79NECCO Wafers Chocolate 2oz Package or 24 Count Box
Spangler Candy CompanyThey are finally back!!! We have waited a long time for these candy wafers to come back and they are finally here after more than 2 years! The same...
View full detailsfrom $1.79Sale -
Sale
from $2.99Skybar 1.5oz Candy Bar or 24ct Box
Skybar CompanyIt's back! Tasting sweeter than ever, this creamy milk chocolate candy bar is filled with great taste and memories! Exactly like the original Skyba...
View full detailsfrom $2.99Sale -
Sale
from $0.99Mini Mini Chicles Gum .79oz Pouch Fruit
Gerrit J. Verburg CompanyDo you miss the old Chiclets? So did we, until we tasted these Mini Mini Chicles. A little thicker, a little bigger, and a little lighter in color ...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sale -
Sale
from $0.99Mini Mini Chicles Gum .58oz Pouch Mint
Gerrit J. Verburg CompanyDo you miss the old Chiclets? So did we, until we tasted these Mini Mini Chicles. A little thicker, a little bigger, and a little lighter in color ...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sale -
Sale
from $1.69Rocky Road 1.65oz Bar Mint
AnnabelleRocky Road Mint is a handmade fluffy mint marshmallow covered with dark chocolate sprinkled with roasted cashew nuts.
from $1.69Sale -
Sale
from $1.69Rocky Road 1.65oz Bar Sea Salt
AnnabelleHandcrafted fluffy vanilla marshmallow, topped with a delicate sprinkle of sea salt, and fresh roasted crushed cashews, individually enrobed in pre...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
Sold out
from $1.69Rocky Road 1.65oz Bar S'mores
AnnabelleRocky Road S’Mores is a handmade fluffy marshmallow with a graham cracker center covered in milk chocolate and topped with roasted cashew nuts.
from $1.69Sold out -
Sale
from $1.69Big Hunk 1.80oz Candy Bar Almond
AnnabelleBig Hunk is a chewy, honey-sweetened nougat bar with whole roasted almonds. Made in the USA.
from $1.69Sale -
Sale
from $1.29Old Dominion Peanut Bar 1.65oz Bar
Hammond's CandiesAre you nutty for nuts? Try the nostalgic Old Dominion Peanut Bar. This salty-sweet snack will cure all your peanut cravings. This classic bar is p...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sale -
Sold out
from $1.79Smarties Squeeze Candy 2.25oz Tube
Ford Gum & Machine CompanyThe great taste of Smarties in a fun liquid squeeze tube. Squeeze away this delicious liquid candy! Delicious Tart & Tangy Mixed-Fruit Flavors.
from $1.79Sold out -
Sold out
from $1.59Warheads Squeeze Candy 2.25oz Tube
Ford Gum & Machine CompanyThe amazing flavor of Warheads Sour Watermelon in a fun, squeezable tube. Hold onto your tongue for the unique sour explosion!! Warheads Sour Water...
View full detailsfrom $1.59Sold out -
Sale
from $1.69100 Grand 1.5oz Candy Bar or 36 Count Box
Ferrero USAA soft and chewy, crunchy, filled with caramel and chocolate covered, totally worth a hundred grand candy bar! There are so many layers of texture ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
Sale
from $1.69Abba Zaba 2oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
AnnabelleThis California candy bar is dubbed as "The best taffy/candy ever made!" and it's lived up to that for decades.
from $1.69Sale -
Sale
$16.75Airheads .55oz Bar 60 Count Box Assorted
Perfetti Van MelleIf you enjoy a fruity candy, you'll just love this old-time favorite! Chewy and juicy - Can't describe it much better!
$16.75Sale