Filters
Nostalgic
-
from $1.19
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Zotz Watermelon 2.1oz Pack or 12 Count Box
Andre ProstA hard, exterior, but a wonderful fizzy center filled with a delicious sour powder. Bite into these candies and let the fizziness take over your ta...
View full detailsfrom $1.19Sold out -
from $1.69
Red Hots 5.5oz Theater Box or 12 Count Case
Ferrara Candy CompanySpicy, Spicy, Spicy! A long-time favorite candy is here to spice things up. Packed in a perfect, theater-sized box for all sorts of uses. Old-time ...
View full detailsfrom $1.69Sale -
$19.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Pixy Sticks Assorted 360 Count Jar
Ferrara Candy CompanySweet and powdery, colorful and sugary. Oh, the sweet things that come from Pixy Sticks! Now available in the perfect jar for any use.
$19.75Sold out -
$19.75
Lemonheads 150 Count Jar
Ferrara Candy CompanyLemonheads are the perfect candy for those that enjoy lemon and sour candy. Just the right amount of sour pucker to sweet. These candies make a del...
View full details$19.75Sale -
from $1.69
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Banana 1.5oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the best, classic flavors for your enjoyment.
from $1.69Sale -
from $1.19
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Zotz Cherry 2.1oz Pack or 12 Count Box
Andre ProstA hard, exterior, but a wonderful fizzy center filled with a delicious sour powder. Bite into these candies and let the fizziness take over your ta...
View full detailsfrom $1.19Sold out -
from $0.99
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Moon Pie Double Decker Strawberry 2.75oz or 9 Count Box
Chattanooga BakeryDo you want dessert but don't have time to bake anything? Look no further than the moon pie. This delicious treat is perfect for a treat or a midni...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sold out -
from $1.29
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Big Cherry Dark Chocolate 1.75oz Bar or 24 Count Box
Adams & BrooksCovered by a rich cream, coated with dark chocolate and topped with peanuts, is where you will find the Big Cherry. Mm, now doesn't that sound so g...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
$5.99
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Wax Sticks 24 Count Box
Charms CompanyA wax stick filled with a fruit flavor liquid, just bite of the top and drink the liquid or chew of pieces for more of a chewy treat.
$5.99Sold out -
$26.75
McCraws Taffy .75oz Assorted Flavors 24 Count Box
Hammond's CandiesAn easy to chew, easy to love nostalgic taffy! McCraws Taffy wasn't being made for a long time, but now it's back and it's better than ever!
$26.75Sale -
from $1.69
Look 1.5oz Candy Bar or 24 Count Box
AnnabelleLook! It's the richest, creamiest candy nougat for decades. Look candy bars will always have you Look!ing for more!
from $1.69Sale -
from $1.69
Crunch 1.55oz Candy Bar or 36 Count Box
Ferrero USAThe Crunch bar is the chocolate candy bar with crisped rice you know and love!
from $1.69Sale -
from $1.19
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Zotz Strawberry 2.1oz Pack or 12 Count Box
Andre ProstA hard, exterior, but a wonderful fizzy center filled with a delicious sour powder. Bite into these candies and let the fizziness take over your ta...
View full detailsfrom $1.19Sold out -
from $1.29
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Vick's Cough Drops Menthol 20 Piece or 20 Count Box
Vick's DropsFast-performing relief is the Vick's promise! Don't let your day go to waste because of an irritated throat. Let Vick's do the job to bring a smile...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
from $1.29
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Vick's Cough Drops Cherry 20 Piece or 20 Count Box
Vick's DropsFast-preforming relief is the Vick's promise! Don't let your day go to waste because of an irritated throat. Let Vick's do the job to bring a smile...
View full detailsfrom $1.29Sold out -
from $0.99
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Licorice Pipe Black 17gr or 60 Count Box
Warrell CorporationLicorice Pipes…the name says it all. A retro staple, these black licorice pipes are individually wrapped. Available in red licorice as well, you ca...
View full detailsfrom $0.99Sold out -
$18.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Beechies Peppermint Gum 2pk 100 Count Box
Roses BrandsEach box is 1.5 inches by 0.875 inches and includes 2 pieces of delicious gum. Beechies gum comes in the icy, refreshing flavor of peppermint.
$18.75Sold out -
$69.75
Rock Crystal .8oz Wrapped Candy Stick 60 Count Box
Roses BrandsCandy Crystals are a gorgeous, sweet rock candy. Full of flavor and perfect for events like weddings, graduations, and birthdays!
$69.75Sale -
from $1.39
LifeSavers Roll Pep-O-Mint .84oz Roll or 20 Count Box
Mars Wrigley ConfectioneryThe mint with the hole. These delightful mints have been around for over 100 years. Each rolls contains 14 LifeSavers candies. The candy was design...
View full detailsfrom $1.39Sold out -
$43.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Bonomo Turkish Taffy Long Twist 192 Count Jar Vanilla Flavored
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the perfect, bite-size twists for on-the-go enjoyment.
$43.75Sold out -
$43.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Bonomo Turkish Taffy Long Twist 192 Count Jar Banana Flavored
Iconic CandyBonomo Turkish Taffy is back after years of waiting! Available now in the perfect, bite-size twists for on-the-go enjoyment.
$43.75Sold out -
from $1.69
Rocky Road 1.65oz Bar Original
AnnabelleAnnabelle’s Rocky Road bars are coated in smooth, handmade milk chocolate with a marshmallow interior. Cashews included. Bonus!
from $1.69Sale -
$11.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Zotz 2.1oz Pack Blue Raspberry 12 Count Box
Andre ProstA hard, exterior, but a wonderful fizzy center filled with a delicious sour powder. Bite into these candies and let the fizziness take over your ta...
View full details$11.75Sold out -
$35.75
DISCONTINUED ITEM - Oh Henry 1.8oz 36 Count Box
Ferrero USAOh Henry! chocolatey, peanutty, caramelly goodness. Oh Henry! Bars consist of two bars inside each pack. Each bar is peanut, caramel, and fudge coa...
View full details$35.75Sold out